I suppose you're right, especially with the hype over it when it was first unveiled such as people's liking to Wizard's design, and thought that the entire cast would be promising. Look at them now... Haruto doesn't show much emotion, Koyomi most of the time stays in the antiques shop where most of her vocabulary is Haruto's name, Rinko doesn't do much police work and tags along with Haruto too often, and Shunpei is just a clown. You thought Rinko would be like Ichijou of Kuuga and Shunpei be a bit like Keitarou of 555. I response to its story, heck, even I can construct a better story for it!In response to the OP's question: I think there are more people who are just disappointed and/or bored with the show than who actually hate it. The main reason seems to be that it got a LOT of hype before it started and, by and large, people have decided it didn't live up to that. I keep seeing comments like "but it had a theme that couldn't go wrong, how did they get it so wrong?"
Don't forget Wiseman, who just hangs around in dark places and lying in his bed most of the time. We only saw one "fight" scene between him and Wizard Infinity Style until Wiseman ended it very quickly by stealing his mana supply. And you're right... a lot of potential has been wasted for the show overall.- Medusa or Phoenix don't really do much. They just... do nothing, except for finfing new gates. I liked them both, but they both are wasted.
That said, I hope to god Gaimu will be something more interesting and worth a watch. So far, people have been hyping over it.
