Well with the ''what if'' thing, we had something to work with. You could probably squeeze a few lol's out of a ''what if'' thread and a few pages of good material. But here all you can do is just go '''yayyyyyyy'' and move on. If it does become a trend it'll be kinda dry, the ''what if'' trend was pretty awesome though.
That epic ''What's your favorite_____'' trend I started about a year ago wins completely.