What, no Nicolas Hammond? :laugh:
I'm really enjoying Josh Keaton on Spectacular so I think he'd have to be my pick, with Chris Barnes as a very close second. Both of these guys are really good at capturing the Peter Parker *and* Spidey side of the character. They can be genuine and sympathetic but also are great at being the high-flying smartass making the villans lose their cool. Which is something that I always found lacking in Tobey's performance.