For me, I prefer a combination of no weapons and with weapons.
The without weapon for me, depends more on the fighting style, rather than just clobbering them, which doesn't appeal to me.
As for the weapons ones, it gets awfully "annoying" when they aren't "good" without their weapon or with, and still don't know how to "fight well".
Not to mention, the excessive "power-ups", which don't even get used that often, that makes it "questionable" why should it end up getting used or debuted at all.
I don't really care what weapons riders end up using, as long as they know how to fight well and use the weapons when they do have it.