Shurikenger
Member
IMO, I don't think that a US version of PGSM wouldn't work. Why? If the US PGSM were to go beyond the Dark Kingdom arc... How would the US version handle Haruka and Michiru's relationship, among other things?
Candidates for Live-Action Sailor Moon US version
- Thread starter arnoldmcguire335
- Start date
Sentaifan'07 Xman
"Let's DRIVING!!!!!"
Exactly my point. Remember the Cloverway version of Sailor Moon S?!
Now that was a nightmare. Worse than the DiC version of Sailor Moon & Sailor Moon R.
My guess is that Disney would waterdown the relationship of Haruka/Sailor Uranus & Michiru/Sailor Neptune because of the issue with the same sex relationships.
arnoldmcguire335
Continuing the Creddie legacy
My dear its all in good fun
Nice. But it will be better is she sang it in ORIGINAL Japanese version. It will sound even better.
If Disney were to pick a bunch of no name nobodys (and me as Usagi) then maybe I would reconsider.....
Well they can do what they did with Camp Rock- Demi Lovato started there. so did Debby Ryan, who debuted in The Suite Life on Deck as Bailey Pickett. and HSM3: Senior year had three newcomers (Two American Boys and One British Girl).
So maybe if Disney did PGSM (either movie or for television), well, hope they start out with newcomers. including you kC.
Shurikenger
Member
I would agree, Xman. I was like, 'WTH? Cousins?'
And furthermore, how would Disney handle the Sailor Starlights?
Ikusa
The World Warrior
I'd rather not know.
Sentaifan'07 Xman
"Let's DRIVING!!!!!"
I don't think anyone would ever touch Sailor Moon Sailor Stars, especially Disney.
They reverted to guy in their casual forms when originally they were girls.
Takeuchi-san wanted to make the Sailor Starlights appear as crossdressing females in the anime originally, but the series director and the company that aired the anime of SMSS screwed it up and made them appear physically as guys instead of girls. Which brought us to the whole controversy of which gender the Sailor Starlights were over the years.
Sheesh.....now is that sheer laziness or what?!
They reverted to guy in their casual forms when originally they were girls.
Takeuchi-san wanted to make the Sailor Starlights appear as crossdressing females in the anime originally, but the series director and the company that aired the anime of SMSS screwed it up and made them appear physically as guys instead of girls. Which brought us to the whole controversy of which gender the Sailor Starlights were over the years.
Sheesh.....now is that sheer laziness or what?!
Shurikenger
Member
While I'm sure that the US has a lot of great talent, to be sure. I'm skeptical of the fact that they could actually pull off the later stuff in Sailor Moon. I'm pretty sure they could handle the original Sailor Moon and a bit of Sailor Moon R... Sailor Moon gets a 'little' complex when S comes around.
Especially the Outer Senshi, and not just Haruka and Michiru. Setsuna Meioh/Sailor Pluto is a pretty deep character (Although, IMHO, Lucy Liu could pull off this role quite well.)... But I'm not so sure whether or not an American actress could pull off Hotaru Tomoe/Sailor Saturn. She's pretty darn complex for a girl her age.
Especially the Outer Senshi, and not just Haruka and Michiru. Setsuna Meioh/Sailor Pluto is a pretty deep character (Although, IMHO, Lucy Liu could pull off this role quite well.)... But I'm not so sure whether or not an American actress could pull off Hotaru Tomoe/Sailor Saturn. She's pretty darn complex for a girl her age.
arnoldmcguire335
Continuing the Creddie legacy
Ok Guys I may have the solution: The Producers can consult with Takeuchi-san on what to do. it may make something better.
and you guys decide what SM version can they use with this clip:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RVVXr7kUOx8
and you guys decide what SM version can they use with this clip:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RVVXr7kUOx8
SaikoDragon
It's Judgement Time!
No it will sound like an american girl trying desperately to pronounce japanese words and keep up a beautiful singing voice and failing.
Winning love by daylight! Never running from a real fight! She is the one named sailor moon! She will neeever turn her back on a frieeend! She is always there to defeeend! She's the one of whom we can DEPEND! She is the one named Sailoooooor! SAILOR MOON!! *dance*
Similar threads
