The Little Mermaid: No you dont want her to be part of your world

10 Comments | Aurora the siren, dark fairy tale, December 17 streaming release, Disney Little Mermaid, Eric the archaeologist, Halle Bailey criticism, Hans Christian Andersen, horror adaptation, Lionsgate The Little Mermaid, Little Mermaid adaptation, Little Mermaid horror, Lydia Helen, modern Little Mermaid, new Little Mermaid movie, public domain fairy tale, red-haired mermaid, siren mythology, sirens vs mermaids, The Little Mermaid, underwater thriller, vampire of the sea. | By Madeline Everleigh | December 7, 2024 | 2 minutes of reading

The Little Mermaid: A Public Domain Tale Takes a Dark Turn

Did you know The Little Mermaid is a public domain story? Hans Christian Andersen’s fairy tale is free for anyone to adapt, as long as their version doesn’t infringe on copyrighted elements, like Disney’s Ariel. That’s why we’ve seen other interpretations, such as the 1980s anime where the mermaid is named Marina. This December 17, Lionsgate will release their own adaptation of The Little Mermaid, and trust me, this one won’t leave you feeling kissed by the sea breeze.

In this chilling reimagining, the titular mermaid, named Aurora, isn’t just a mermaid, she’s a siren. Sirens, often seen as the vampires of the sea, lure sailors with their beauty and angelic voices before devouring them. With a plot this dark, part of your world becomes part of her menu.

For Those Seeking a “Classic” Look

If you’re among those who got poor unfortunate souls over the race swap in Disney’s live-action Little Mermaid, here’s your chance to see a red-haired mermaid. Aurora is portrayed by Lydia Helen, who bears a striking resemblance to what some fans envision as the “classic Ariel.” That said, let’s not forget the hate Halle Bailey received for her portrayal of Ariel in Disney’s adaptation was uncalled for, Bailey nailed it with her voice and delivered a performance that deserves respect.

The Little Mermaid Trailer

But let’s be honest: the original Little Mermaid was already a horror story. In Andersen’s tale, the mermaid sacrifices everything, only to die and turn into sea foam. You might say that life under the sea was always filled with tragedy, making a horror adaptation feel inevitable.

A Modern Take on a Timeless Tale

This version of The Little Mermaid is set in the present day. Eric, traditionally a prince, is reimagined as an archaeologist researching a dangerous and all-powerful sea god. Unbeknownst to him, he’s already dating her. Aurora, with her angelic face, red hair, and sparkling eyes, looks like she’s got gadgets and gizmos aplenty. But don’t let her innocent charm fool you, she’s got a hunger for your soul that won’t stop at dinglehoppers.

This December, Lionsgate’s adaptation will show us that not all mermaids want to be where the people are, some just want to make them part of the sea floor.

Help Support PopGeeks

PopGeeks runs on reader support. We are not backed by corporate media, driven by algorithms, or overloaded with invasive ads. We are an independently run site created by fans, for fans, and we cover what we love: movies, TV, video games, comics, and tabletop RPGs.

Support PopGeeks for just $1/month and help keep our content free and ad-light. Your support covers hosting, pays our writers, and helps sustain independent coverage of movies, games, TV, and geek culture. Every dollar makes a difference.

This is a voluntary support payment. No physical goods or exclusive digital content are provided. PopGeeks content remains freely accessible to all. Sales tax does not apply.

Thank you for reading. Thank you for caring. And thank you for helping PopGeeks stay fan-run, freely accessible, and fully independent.

10 replies

Join the discussion →

Loading new replies...

Awakens

AMAWEMEN Hear me roar!

651 messages 39 likes

#1 Dec 09, 2024

Sounds like they're taking a dark turn for no reason. The ocean already faces enough threats with pollution and climate change. Do we really need a movie that portrays mermaids as scary monsters? It perpetuates negative stereotypes and could discourage people from protecting our oceans.

Reply Like

Palace Kitty

Crazy!

369 messages 9 likes

#2 Dec 09, 2024

Looks like the folks who couldn't handle a Black Ariel got their wish. A white mermaid, but with a twist. Guess they forgot the original story wasn't exactly a feel-good tale.

It's ironic how the same people who complained about a diverse cast are now getting a version that's darker and more gruesome. Perhaps they should've considered the original story before making their racist remarks.

Karma's a b*tch, isn't it?

Reply Like

Shady Side

New Member

664 messages 28 likes

#3 Dec 09, 2024

This reimagining could be visually striking! Imagine the underwater scenes with a dark and gothic vibe. The contrast between Aurora's innocent beauty and her monstrous side could be incredibly interesting to see. Definitely looking forward to seeing the costume design and special effects.

Reply Like

tiffanyfcollins

Member

46 messages 1 like

#4 Dec 09, 2024

Seriously, another public domain horror reimagining? It's getting old, really old. Can't Hollywood come up with something original? This constant trend of twisting classic tales into cheap horror gimmicks is not only lazy but also disrespectful to the original authors and their work.

It's like they're taking something beloved and cherished and turning it into a grotesque caricature. It's a shame that such talented filmmakers and actors are wasting their time on these hollow projects.

Reply Like

Brave Maeve

New Member

16 messages 0 likes

#5 Dec 09, 2024

Oh great, another movie that uses nostalgia to sell tickets. "Remember that story you loved as a kid? Well, get ready for it to be dark and depressing!" Hollywood has no shame. Maybe they should focus on creating stories that haven't been done a million times already.

Reply Like

Datass

Member

137 messages 3 likes

#6 Dec 09, 2024

A dark and creepy Little Mermaid?! Sign me up! I loved the Disney version when I was little, but it sounds like this one will be way more intense. A siren mermaid who eats sailors? That's so messed up, but in a totally awesome way. Plus, a red-haired mermaid like the original? Sold.

Reply Like

Tampalpuke

Ariel's Bestfriend

90 messages 1 like

#7 Dec 09, 2024

This is just sad. Why ruin something that brought so much joy to so many people? It's like they're trying to take away our happy memories. I'll stick to the original Disney version, thank you very much. They'll ruin anything for a quick buck. First Pooh Bear, now Ariel? What's next, a horror remake of Cinderella?

Reply Like

Bruno

You Don't talk about!

1,049 messages 31 likes

#8 Dec 09, 2024

This is just sad. Why ruin something that brought so much joy to so many people? It's like they're trying to take away our happy memories. I'll stick to the original Disney version, thank you very much. They'll ruin anything for a quick buck. First Pooh Bear, now Ariel? What's next, a horror remake of Cinderella?

I am sorry to break it to you but 2 of them already exists.

Reply Like