Black Fang
Active Member
The problem here is that Shinji's words seemed to be backed up by the movie's events that followed. Femme was shown to be utterly incompetent in combat every time she engaged the other Riders.
She was incompetent in the battle where Kanzaki played the church organ? She injures Kitaoka at one point (either here or another scene, I can't recall which), so it's not as though she was just kicked around.
But besides that, so what if Shinji was "proven" right? Miho entered the Game with the same kind of desires as the men, so what really differentiates her from the rest beyond sex? What's wrong with Shinji thinking that anyway? No one condemns him or Ren for telling that kid that he shouldn't be a part of this. Though I suppose that's ok because it was a boy.
Maybe Shinji just didn't like the idea of a young girl involved in such a horrendous thing, much less anyone else? It's not as though he cheered the idea of the men being involved, so you can't pin it on "Oh he didn't mind men being Riders". Why is that so awful?
Asakura grabbed her by the neck even after he lost his deck and she just stood there unable to get out. It seemed like if he hadn't been vaporized due to the mirror world, he could have beat her up even without transforming.
We've seen what Asakura is capable of. Is it that hard to believe he could pull that off?
There were no signs that she was tired. It was only afterwards that she tried to hide her wound until she died.
I don't recall.
I don't see how Shinji's speech could be the same if she was male. Quite a few elements of her character would be changed by that, and, yes, that would result in some other meaning for her role.
So if she was a male schoolkid instead of a girl, there would be that much of a difference? How? I don't see it.
Plus all females tend to be put into the love interest spot, because, surprise surprise, Japan isn't a feminist "we don't need no man" country.
Yet this is the same country with a dismal birth rate and less and less women getting married and pursuing careers instead? How does that jive?
You'll never see a male character in toku who exists just to be a love interest (except maybe Tuxedo Mask in PGSM - and that's based on an anime/manga, so it's not quite the same thing.) Therefore there shouldn't be female characters who exist just for that. They should be written the same way.
Don't kid yourself. If such a character came around you'd be complaining about her too because she's too "manly". And how is it not the same thing just because something's based on a comic? Kamen Rider is originally derived from a comic.