Scott Pilgrim vs. The World - Talk UP! (SPOILERS)

I hadn't read the book and the movie's pacing felt fine to me. There was enough explanation of things to be evocative and believable. I certainly didn't have any moments of just WHY IS THIS HAPPENING THIS DOESN'T MAKE ANY SENSE. And maybe the explanations I filled in for stuff like the vegan powers weren't the "correct" ones from the book, but you have to ask yourself: how important are those explanations, actually, to the basic story being told?
 
What's weird is that the part where they explain the vegan powers is exactly the same. I just believed it more in the book. Maybe it's just me personally.:sweat:
 
I didn't need any extra evidence or explanation to "believe" anything. The movie is so unabashedly ridiculous that I just accepted everything that it threw at me without a second though because of how amazing it was. But then, not everyone is in love with the patently ridiculous the way I am. Anyway, the film worked perfectly for me, someone who has never read more than 50 pages of the comics (yet) but not so well for my girlfriend, a die-hard fan of comic from the start. (She had a lot of fun with it though!)

I must say that I am mildly annoyed by the people claiming that this film's target audience was far too narrow, though. I am 22, yes, but I only have a very cursory knowledge of video games - the only system I own is a DS that I bought two months ago and before that it was a Gameboy and an NES that I received when I was in the hospital when I was five. Aside from that, there are a small handful of computer games I have played to some extent but overall I am largely unknowledgeable in this field, meaning that I don't fall into the supposed "gamer" target audience. The only reference I got apart from the most basic video game concepts (extra lives, money, experience, the set-up of a fighting game) was the use of the Sonic ring sound effect.

Then there is the idea that it appeals to the indie music crowd. Well, I know I listen to and like indie music some but I'm certainly not part of that subculture or whatever. Not to mention that my primary indie fix is Japanese - a far cry from Toronto.

And of course let's not forget all the 30-to-50-year-olds out there who saw the film and dug it just as much as I did, even though a lot of them probably had even less knowledge about video games than myself!

None of that is the reason I enjoyed the film. It contributed, yes, but my favorite parts were things like the vegan superpowers, the crazy ways one scene would cut into the next, the random absurdities abounding in every frame and just the general comic timing of it all. I loved the scene where the studio laugh track is used, for example, for its pure absurdity without ever realizing that it was meant to be a Seinfeld homage! Or Knives' forlorn "nooooooo!" in the background of another scene. Honestly, despite the obvious video game influences, video game homages were the least of what made the film entertaining for me.

Really, I think the movie could have a much broader audience than people think except that A) people write it off as being exactly what I just said it wasn't and B) lots of people aren't as ready to accept hyperkinetic absurdity the way I am(?). I don't know. Those are my thoughts, mostly.
 
Yeah, I don't think the movie or the graphic novel targeted a specific subset of people. I think the creators just drew on their own inspirations and interests and crafted something that allowed the story they were trying to tell to be told and be relatable to audiences who enjoy the same things.
 
I think the man problem was how fast everything seemed to move. From one ex to the next just moved so fast it's hard to make a plot. A

I didnt think it moved that fast at all. Because the 'exes' were only part of the plot. The speed at which the 'exes' came around didnt disorient me because the main plot was mostly on Scott's relationships and his band. the plot surrounding how the band gets their first gig, succeeds, then goes on to the next, and then gets signed, really helped tie in all the encounters and experiences in the movie.

I hadn't read the book and the movie's pacing felt fine to me. There was enough explanation of things to be evocative and believable. I certainly didn't have any moments of just WHY IS THIS HAPPENING THIS DOESN'T MAKE ANY SENSE. And maybe the explanations I filled in for stuff like the vegan powers weren't the "correct" ones from the book, but you have to ask yourself: how important are those explanations, actually, to the basic story being told?

agreed. Honestly, I didnt care about the special powers. Again, I viewed all these interesting special powers as something of a wild imagining of how Scott views these types of people.

And it was really fun seeing how Scott would defeat each ex creatively instead of straight forward brute force.

The final confrontation was just amazing. You think Scott will have this awesome, video game style duel with Nega Scott. But in reality, he walks out as 'friends'. It's as if the character was coming to terms with himself and his darker sides. As if he was accepting his imperfections. So again, this movie had a lot to like about it.
 
SaikoDragon said:
agreed. Honestly, I didnt care about the special powers. Again, I viewed all these interesting special powers as something of a wild imagining of how Scott views these types of people.

I saw it the same way.
 
agreed. Honestly, I didnt care about the special powers. Again, I viewed all these interesting special powers as something of a wild imagining of how Scott views these types of people.

According to Wikipedia, the book's creator said that this is how it is.
But remember, this is Wikipedia and Wikipedia is a better liar than Satan himself.
 
I didnt think it moved that fast at all. Because the 'exes' were only part of the plot. The speed at which the 'exes' came around didnt disorient me because the main plot was mostly on Scott's relationships and his band. the plot surrounding how the band gets their first gig, succeeds, then goes on to the next, and then gets signed, really helped tie in all the encounters and experiences in the movie.



agreed. Honestly, I didnt care about the special powers. Again, I viewed all these interesting special powers as something of a wild imagining of how Scott views these types of people.

And it was really fun seeing how Scott would defeat each ex creatively instead of straight forward brute force.

The final confrontation was just amazing. You think Scott will have this awesome, video game style duel with Nega Scott. But in reality, he walks out as 'friends'. It's as if the character was coming to terms with himself and his darker sides. As if he was accepting his imperfections. So again, this movie had a lot to like about it.

I never realized that before. I knew that Scott Pilgrim was how any person has fears of if he can live up to or best his girlfriend's exes, albeit in a geeky way of seeing things, but that makes a whole lot of sense. Matthew Patel was like a Hindu god that summoned demons, the Vegan was like a crazy Super Saiyan, and the final one was like the all powerful administrator of any computer or website forum.

Nega Scott was funny . I felt the same way you did about that part.


All in all it was a well put together film.
 

Latest News & Videos

Latest News

Back
Top