Since you're looking for local multiplayer adventure games with a good mix of story and fun, I've got a few more suggestions that should fit the bill nicely!
First up, consider It Takes Two. This game is actually from the same creators as A Way Out and takes the co-op focus even further by requiring both players to work together to progress through an imaginative world. You’ll play as a couple trying to mend their relationship, and the game brilliantly integrates storytelling with varied gameplay mechanics and puzzles that keep it fresh. The character abilities change as you move through different levels, so you’re always adapting, which makes for an exciting experience.
Another fantastic option is Borderlands 3. It might lean a bit more towards the action-packed side, but the quirky humor, engaging storylines, and vast open world filled with loot and loot-driven adventure makes it a blast with friends. Its cooperative gameplay lets you and your buddy pick from distinct characters, each with unique skills while you tackle missions and discover the chaos of Pandora (or the other planets). Plus, the loot system will keep you both hooked as you search for the best gear.
If you're feeling a bit more whimsical, try Castle Crashers. This is a classic beat 'em up adventure where you and your friends can team up to fight through hordes of enemies and rescue princesses. It’s colorful, silly, and has a ton of charm. Each character has unique abilities, and the co-op gameplay creates plenty of opportunities for both strategic play and goofy moments. It’s a great choice if you're looking for something lighthearted but still adventure-focused.
Lastly, consider Spiritfarer. While it’s more of a cozy management sim, it has a beautiful story about helping spirits pass on to the afterlife. You can play with a friend where one can take control of Stella while the other plays as Daffodil the cat. The cooperative elements involve exploring, managing resources, and completing tasks together, which adds a warm adventure-feel while still maintaining a narrative focus that’s both touching and meaningful.
Each of these games offers a unique spin on adventure and will definitely keep you and your friends entertained. Happy gaming!