Best X-Men Movie

[guyincognito]

What are you talking about. The movies have their own canon.

^This.

---------------------------

Earth Designation: Marvel-199999.

Marvel and D.C. have been doing AU for along time.

 

[bigone]

I would have gone with X-Men, but Origins: Cyclops is up there.



Huh?



This.



Yeah, me too.



That has nothing to do with it, and "cannon"?



I have no idea what this means. If you mean to say that Ishinomori stopped providing Saban with rights to Black RX's footage, then that's different. It was an adaptation with a very different story and with different characters that he did not like that used stock footage from another series. He didn't like that it was being used for something he could never imagine. The X-Men movies have an adapted storyline of their own. They follow their own storyline and they are canonical to their own story except for Origins: Wolverine. They are based on the comics, but they aren't the comics in movie format. That would take many more movies. Please work on your writing.

i happen to have alot of X men comics so ud like a movie made based directly from a Comic arc or maybe based on Chuck Austin stuff i like his work

 

[Skiks]

You could but a lot of X stories will need to be adapted anyways because they would not make for a good movie.

 

[Darkster]

Yes, it's not like you can take the comics and just use them as a script.

 

[bigone]

if manga can be adapted in to movies comics should be able to be
just to name some Oldboy Azumi 13 GTO Higurashi no Naku Koro ni Lady Snowblood just to name some
if western comics are so much better than manga as you guys seam to think they are fromthe thread i made on that exact Subject
then how come on direct Comic book adaptations
no Gwen Stacy in Spiderman or no Carnage in spiderman yet
on Dark knight Returns Movie [ imo joint best Comic Ever] so Frank Miller can do Crap like 300 and Sin city but not make a movie from his best ever work

 

[Darkster]

Did you watch Spiderman 3? :sly: Gwen Stacy was in it. Comics usually are longer than manga and they get started by different people at many times. You want to talk canonical? First take that into consideration.

I also think more people like manga over comics and one of the reasons I like them more is that there are some that are shorter, more creative, and consistent than most comics. That's why I stopped reading comics.

 

[bigone]

Did you watch Spiderman 3? :sly: Gwen Stacy was in it. Comics usually are longer than manga and they get started by different people at many times. You want to talk canonical? First take that into consideration.

I also think more people like manga over comics and one of the reasons I like them more is that there are some that are shorter, more creative, and consistent than most comics. That's why I stopped reading comics.

but marvel are good at Explaining bad canonical continuity usely so why mess up both spideman and X men canonical and in terms of continuity the first line up of the X team was Cyclops Beast Iceman Angel/Archangel Marvel Girl/Phoenix Mimic Changeling Polaris Havok
not only that no 2000s recreutes for a s movie from the 2000s to have no 2000's characters in the team no Domino Aurora Xorn or Cable

also no Madelyne Pryor yet
she may have been it in but since no death by Green Goblin

 

[Darkster]

I honestly have no idea what that post means. Please restate it. Add punctuations as well because I read it as a run-on sentence.

 

[bigone]

I honestly have no idea what that post means. Please restate it. Add punctuations as well because I read it as a run-on sentence.

im just explaining the fact that i have no idea were if you were to compere it to Proper cannon witch i do Were does each movie fall

 

[KingRanger]

im just explaining the fact that i have no idea were if you were to compere it to Proper cannon witch i do Were does each movie fall

:redface2::sly::disappoin:eyebrow::shakefist