Tigh being a skinjob is what's set me thinking the most. That and this quote here "it was about the creation of the cylons 50 years ago.." So yeah, with Tigh... it'd be impossible. I was thinking about this with some others. They were kids a long time ago and have histories that everyone knows.
I don't think they'd go the clone route cuz that would be cheap.
But I've been saying since Season 1 that there's a third alien party out there. The gods of Kobol.
Remember when they found Kobol there's the legend that some alien race worked with the humans to get them going. Then Boomer says, "We know more about your religion than you do."
Since then I figured that Phantom Six and Phantom Baltar are alien entities... gods of Kobol.
That and that when the mech Cylons went out to space they found the gods out there and brought 'em back for the big war.
"What if God felt he made a mistake with the humans?" So, the gods came back to wipe out the humans.
These aliens/gods have been around for a long time it sounds like, so they could have planeted some of their own in the human race like Tigh, Boomer, and the others.
That these Final Five are singing an Earth song could mean this third party has ties to Earth.
Kara being back was a surprise. I knew she'd be back, but I thought she wsa gonna come back late in the next or final season.
Didn't we see her ship blow up and debris fly everywhere? I could see Kara coming back, but her ship? Her return, I thought meant she was the Fifth Cylon and it would explain how she was able to get visions and the such.
Another curious thing... Roslin getting woozey and powering down the same time the fleet did. I was thinking, could the blood she got infused with be changing her?
I really liked the rock opera ending. Something about the way it was ending with the guitar rockin' gave me a feeling of Beast Wars or something.
5/5
Awesome... but motherlovin' brutal we gotta frackin' wait 'til 2008 to see new episodes. >__O
EDIT: Another thing, if they're hearing songs from Earth, maybe the Cylons are artificial humans from a destroyed Earth. The Earth got used up, destroyed, and the human race had to go out and colonize out in space, running into the gods of Kobol along the way to create the 12 colonies.
Left behind were the 12 artificial humans that maybe want the humans to pay for the crimes they visited on Earth.