out of order

Brandon Routh Is Out Of Order In New Comedy

You know that old sitcom chestnut about the teenager who asks out two girls, and then tries to keep both dates at once? That fabled buffoon has nothing on John Slater, the lawyer played by Brandon Routh in the upcoming comedy Out Of Order.

Slater is a big-shot lawyer…well, he wishes he was. His stalled career and the dumpy firm he works for have turned off his snobby supermodel girlfriend, who figures she can do better. John wants to prove he can, and manages to finally land a position at one of the biggest firms in the city. There’s just one problem…he kinda hasn’t quit his old job yet. His boss had a heart attack and it was the man’s dying wish that John take this one last case. Well, no problem — he’ll just take both cases at once. But OF COURSE they’re the same case, on opposing sides of the courtroom.

So John has to invent Jack Slater, a different persona, to keep up the charade. There is no trailer yet, and very few screenshots, so our question is: how does this guy play two lawyers at the same time in the same room?

Out Of Order was directed by Guy Jacobson (Priority Films) and co-written by Jacobson and Megan Freels Johnston. “Out of Order was born from my years in Big Law,” said Jacobson. “It’s a return to the kind of physical, character-driven comedy we don’t see enough of today, part My Cousin Vinny, part Mrs. Doubtfire, with a dash of Office Space and a sprinkle of A Fish Called Wanda. I wanted to make something gloriously ridiculous but grounded in real emotion.”

This has a pretty stacked cast for something relatively indie: in addition to Routh, cast members include the likes of Brooke Shields, Sam Huntington, Luis Guzmán, Michael Potts, Sandra Bernhard, Tao Okamoto, Krysta Rodriguez, and Asher Grodman. Out of Order debuted at the Chelsea Film Festival on Opening Night; a distribution deal has yet to be announced.

out of order poster v3

Join the club!

Video interviews, reviews, game news, and pure fandom - be the first to know!

Help Support PopGeeks

PopGeeks runs on reader support. We are not backed by corporate media, driven by algorithms, or overloaded with invasive ads. We are an independently run site created by fans, for fans, and we cover what we love: movies, TV, video games, comics, and tabletop RPGs.

Support PopGeeks for just $1/month and help keep our content free and ad-light. Your support covers hosting, pays our writers, and helps sustain independent coverage of movies, games, TV, and geek culture. Every dollar makes a difference.

This is a voluntary support payment. No physical goods or exclusive digital content are provided. PopGeeks content remains freely accessible to all. Sales tax does not apply.

Thank you for reading. Thank you for caring. And thank you for helping PopGeeks stay fan-run, freely accessible, and fully independent.

Loading new replies...

Avatar of TJN
TJN

Member

153 messages 4 likes

Brandon Routh deserves more comedic roles. Heโ€™s always had that charming but slightly awkward energy that works perfectly for this kind of setup. The idea of a lawyer pretending to be two different people on opposite sides of the same case sounds absurd, but in a good way. It feels like something from the 90s that we havenโ€™t seen in a while. I like that the director said he wanted to make something โ€œgloriously ridiculous but grounded.โ€ If they can balance the humor with some genuine emotion, this could actually be a surprise hit.

Reply Like

Avatar of Samantha Who?
Samantha Who?

adventure flute vase

155 messages 2 likes

I actually love this premise. It reminds me of old screwball comedies where the lead is trapped in their own lies and keeps making things worse. Brandon Routh is an underrated actor, and seeing him take on a double performance sounds fun. Also, Brooke Shields and Luis Guzmรกn in the same movie? Thatโ€™s already worth checking out.

Reply Like

Avatar of $erenity
$erenity

When you cut me, I bleed pink

230 messages 17 likes

This sounds funny, but also stressful. Playing two lawyers fighting the same case sounds like a nightmare scenario. I think Routh can pull it off though; he has good comedic timing, especially if youโ€™ve seen him in Chuck or Legends of Tomorrow. Hopefully this gets picked up by a streaming service soon

Reply Like

Avatar of 0preretgf90
0preretgf90

New Member

51 messages 0 likes

Itโ€™s nice to see Brandon Routh doing something fresh. I still remember him as Superman, but his best work has been in smaller projects where he can play quirky characters. This concept sounds old-fashioned but in a comforting way. A comedy that doesnโ€™t rely on crude jokes but on situation and personality could really stand out today.

Reply Like

Avatar of Princess Zakiya
Princess Zakiya

The Princess of the Ball

149 messages 12 likes

The cast list surprised me. Brooke Shields and Sandra Bernhard together is such a random but interesting mix. I think this kind of ensemble could make the humor more unpredictable. Iโ€™m curious to see if Routhโ€™s two characters ever โ€œfaceโ€ each other in court through editing tricks. That could be hilarious if done well.

Reply Like