Why Super Hero Taisen GP: Kamen Rider #3 Debuts at #6 in japan box office ?

Yeah, that's understandable.
Let's also remember as fans, that whether Odagiri Joe likes toku or not is his own opinion and whether he wants to come back to toku is also his own right.
Its pointless holding grudges for an actor over his own choices on that matter, especially when Kuuga is done and over with and what we got is still a good show with a good lead who did not half-ass it. No matter how much toku fans like Kuuga, he really isn't obligated for anything more than that.
Being able to idolize toku actors who like the genre and are more than willing to come back to it is ultimately a privilege and a bonus.

And, let's be frank here, it isn't as if his problem with the sort of Toei production style is unfounded given all the things we've heard...

But these movies just aren't interested in building onto a show or writing a good storyline around old characters and actually USING characters; they just want old faces to slap onto the poster to drum up interest in their 90 minute fighting game masquerading as a movie.
I will argue that the last two Taisen movies, Rider Taisen and Taisen GP, do seem to have more ambitions and interest in building a story using these characters or at least have a story that actually has something more interesting going on to begin with.
Though that is almost exclusively due to the involvement of Shibasaki really, and I can't imagine it lasting very long until they inevitably milk him dry permanently, or get another guy with a 50-50 chance of being anywhere near interesting.
Or just stop making these movies when its still on some sort of high-note.
 
I don't expect every actor involved with toku -- or any show or movie I like -- to be fans of the series or whatever genre it's a part of. In fact, I get irked when people try too hard to prove that they're fans. (It used to be fun to read newly cast toku actors enthusiastically talk about what toku shows inspired them growing up; now it seems phony and like a scripted requirement at all premieres and initial interviews.)

My problem with people like Joe Odagiri with toku or Daniel Craig with James Bond is...they feel they have to go that extra step to prove how much "cooler" or "above" the material they feel they are. Just leave it at "Actually, I'm not a fan of [toku/James Bond/Star Trek/whatever], but I'm giving my best to this material." That's a bummer, but that beats "This stuff is ****! I'm a REAL actor! Do you know how lucky you are that a person of my ability is lowering themselves for this campy, low brow ****?!" (FTR, this isn't anybody's actual quote, but a hyperbolic amalgamation of what tends to be said about genre works by actors with contempt for the genre they feel trapped in.)
 
Aw, thanks.

As a Kuuga fan, it was disappointing for me to find out all of the ugly details about the "Joe Odagiri saga." I've made my dislike of his statements and similar statements well known. I've tracked the ordeal and will present the shebang here, and as objectively as I can. (And I will lazily copy and repaste this whenever the topic comes up.)

It's 1998 and Odagiri is just starting his career. Like many a Japanese actors at the start of their career, his manager looks to tokusatsu as a nice, steady regular gig for a newcomer, and arranges for Odagiri to audition for a Super Sentai. (From Joe's comments referring to the show as being a "year prior to Kuuga," it is presumed that it's GoGoFive he was sent to auditioned for. However, I've wondered if it was really Gingaman, considering Gingaman and Kuuga share the same main producer, Shigenori Takatera, and the story goes that some high up at Toei kept Odagiri in mind for when Kuuga was being cast.)

Odagiri balks at the idea of doing a tokusatsu. He balks hard. "I'm a real actor," he says. "Henshin heroes make me sick," is his reasoning, and one of his oft-quoted lines. When thinking of doing a tokusatsu he wanted to "either die or just give up acting." He's still made to audition and, according to him, he purposely gave a terrible audition in the hopes of never being called back to audition for a tokusatsu series.

It didn't work. Somebody at Toei liked him and made note of him and thought of him when it came time to cast Kuuga. Like Black, Kuuga was a big deal, the popular Rider series' first time on television in quite a while. Pretty much every actor of a particular age in Japan tried out for the lead role. Thinking he was clear of ever having to audition for a tokusatsu, Odagiri's not too happy about his agency arranging for his being seen about Kuuga. But he has to listen to his manager and agency, so he goes...

As we all know, Kuuga was a different approach to tokusatsu, unlike anything tokusatsu had done at that point. That was the goal of Kuuga producer Shigenori Takatera; he wanted to change the face of tokusatsu and he and writer Naruhisa Arakawa wanted it to feel more like an American drama. Odagiri meets with Takatera and finds his pitch fascinating. He doesn't like tokusatsu, but this sounds like something he could see himself doing, something he feels he could sink his teeth into. Takatera's pretty sure he's found his Godai. Odagiri admits that he's never seen a single Kamen Rider series, so Takatera arranges for several episodes of the original series to be sent to Odagiri. Odagiri claims he only watched a little before being completely turned off of the idea again. ("I can't do this kind of stuff!" is his quote) Takatera reassures him and lays out further plans of how his show will be nothing like those old ones. On a leap of faith, Odagiri decides to take the role.

Odagiri has said many, many times that he ended up enjoying the show, he's proud of the success Kuuga had, and that he made friends with a lot of the cast and crew and remains friends with most of them to this day. (IIRC, he even attended the wedding of the actress who played Godai's sister.) Up until that soundbite he gave a TV show (the one that the Tokusatsu Network reported about), he never said anything negative about Kuuga, the show or its quality, itself. His negativity was directed at tokusatsu as a whole, with his own show exempt.

There's been some misunderstanding about his feelings on Kuuga. In some interviews, he's mentioned how difficult and nightmarish it was to make Kuuga, but in a lot of those instances, he was referring to the shooting schedule and the physical demands of the series. Those sentiments, over the years, got entangled with his negativity about the genre as a whole and was warped into a "Odagiri hates Kuuga" thing when that wasn't the issue. Like I said, he had gone on record numerous times saying he liked Kuuga itself. Even with that interview he did that Tokusatsu Network reported about, I've wondered if he was taken out of context slightly or if he was misunderstood. (A lot of what he said was the same thing he always said. "I hated doing it at the time" could easily have been referring to his early feelings.)

If you want to give Odagiri the benefit of doubt, then a majority of his toku-bashing quotes came from that issue of Pict-Up magazine from 2005, just as his popularity was taking off. Could his toku bashing have been bravado, since he's after an indie movie image, an image that doesn't line-up with the star of a hero show? Nobody wants to be typecast, was it his attempt to separate himself from the past and branch out? The general public has their own simplistic idea of what Kamen Rider and tokusatsu is all about, can Joe really be expected to go into all of the minute details about how different Kuuga was each time his being a Rider was brought up?

Still, the idea of him doing one of these Rider movies, right now, is out of the question. Kuuga producer Takatera would definitely need to be involved, and he still has some bad blood over Hibiki. (Which might be letting up, since he recently Tweeted to Toei producers Hideaki Tsukada and Takahito Ohmori the idea of doing an early Heisei VS later Heisei Rider movie.) I think Odagiri will "stoop" and come back to tokusatsu on his own when his mainstream popularity dips and his mainstream roles dry up, or if his kids end up talking him into it. Fans will have to be patient -- Godai won't be returning in a Taisen flick any time soon, but fans could possibly end up seeing a Godai who's nearing 60 in a Rider movie down the road.
_______

(End of objectivity.)

I think there's interesting ways to involve Kuuga or Hibiki characters in these movies, though, but it involves creativity and storytelling capabilities, which Shirakura and Yonemura strongly lack. You could bring back Ichijou and give him G3-Unit armor, keeping that blasted Kuuga and Agito "connection;" you could take the idea from Arakawa's novel of having Mika be a new Kuuga warrior. For Hibiki, you could RIGHT THE SHOW'S WRONGS by bringing back Asumu and having him be the new Hibiki. But these movies just aren't interested in building onto a show or writing a good storyline around old characters and actually USING characters; they just want old faces to slap onto the poster to drum up interest in their 90 minute fighting game masquerading as a movie.

And for the record, I don't like misinformation. I do my best to research and squash that ****.



Hmm from what i read you are saying that joe odagari doesn't like being part of hero genre tokusatsu at the time few years before takign the kuuga role and i see why he takes the kuuga because he heard that the kuuga series will be different than other regular tokusatsu series including super sentai so he gives it a try after he took the kuuga role he kinda likes the show and the role but still doesn't like the conditions of the hero genre tokusatsu because it feels you know cheap but at least he consider the actors and the production crew as friends and family that he sometimes attend for its reunion party.


maybe if there is a kamen rider show on its anniversary where it will do the format of gokaiger and decade by paying tribute to the previous and to include the past actors as guest 'stars and if there is a episode dedicated to kuuga maybe joe odagari would reprise his role as yusuke godai/kuuga but only if its tone and atmosphere in that episode will be faithful to the kuuga series and and will respectfully pay tribute to it similar to what gokaiger did with the jetman episode with black condor.

Well anyway if toei will apologies to kuugas producer Shigenori Takatera and rehire him for a future kamen rider crossover film similar like superhero taisen and movie war then maybe joe odagari will reprise his role as yusuke godai/Kuuga but only if the conditions are suitable for him unlike the regular which is usual in every tokusatsu hero genre production shows .I mean perhaps joe odagari will end up like the late Leonard Nimoy someday after all Leonard once doesn't like the role of Spock after the series ended but many years later he jsut embrace and admitted that his role is great that he reprises it for the 2009 film.

Maybe someday joe odagari will reprise his role yusuke godai/Kuuga someday after all the guy is still in his 30's or 40's ;)

and by the way as for what you said about Kaoru Ichijo wearing the G3 armour , Mika becoming the new kuuga (probably canon or non canon i am not sure) and Asumu Adachi becoming the new hibiki i think this idea will look awesome if it happens in some superhero taisen or movie war it will have a ally or someone inspired by the original heisei or showa rider to take his place while the originals are fighting in some type of battle in the other area off screen for example in some kamen rider anniversary themed season similar like gokaiger or some crossover film like superhero taisen or movie war Asumu Adachi as hibiki will rescue the current rider who is in deep trouble by a monster he defeats him with his weapon and then after the monster is defeated the current rider untransforms and thanks hibiki but as asumu turns off his hibiki form the current rider is confused where the original hibiki is Asamu then tells him the original hibiki is just fighting in a different battle whichwill be off camera or he will probably retire and let asamu take his place instead.

Yeah, that's understandable.
Let's also remember as fans, that whether Odagiri Joe likes toku or not is his own opinion and whether he wants to come back to toku is also his own right.
Its pointless holding grudges for an actor over his own choices on that matter, especially when Kuuga is done and over with and what we got is still a good show with a good lead who did not half-ass it. No matter how much toku fans like Kuuga, he really isn't obligated for anything more than that.
Being able to idolize toku actors who like the genre and are more than willing to come back to it is ultimately a privilege and a bonus.

And, let's be frank here, it isn't as if his problem with the sort of Toei production style is unfounded given all the things we've heard...

You said it brother, Joe will someday reprise his role as kuuga for the fans if the conditions in the tokusatsu productions are suitable for him if they rehire Shigenori Takatera or if the fans really want him to play kuuga one more time or at least act as a cameo without costume during the end of the rider movie war or taisen movie as jsut yusuke godai but not to have his voice play as kuuga just let him be silent.


I will argue that the last two Taisen movies, Rider Taisen and Taisen GP, do seem to have more ambitions and interest in building a story using these characters or at least have a story that actually has something more interesting going on to begin with.
Though that is almost exclusively due to the involvement of Shibasaki really, and I can't imagine it lasting very long until they inevitably milk him dry permanently, or get another guy with a 50-50 chance of being anywhere near interesting.
Or just stop making these movies when its still on some sort of high-note.

You do have a good point there
 
Last edited:
I don't expect every actor involved with toku -- or any show or movie I like -- to be fans of the series or whatever genre it's a part of. In fact, I get irked when people try too hard to prove that they're fans. (It used to be fun to read newly cast toku actors enthusiastically talk about what toku shows inspired them growing up; now it seems phony and like a scripted requirement at all premieres and initial interviews.)

My problem with people like Joe Odagiri with toku or Daniel Craig with James Bond is...they feel they have to go that extra step to prove how much "cooler" or "above" the material they feel they are. Just leave it at "Actually, I'm not a fan of [toku/James Bond/Star Trek/whatever], but I'm giving my best to this material." That's a bummer, but that beats "This stuff is ****! I'm a REAL actor! Do you know how lucky you are that a person of my ability is lowering themselves for this campy, low brow ****?!" (FTR, this isn't anybody's actual quote, but a hyperbolic amalgamation of what tends to be said about genre works by actors with contempt for the genre they feel trapped in.)

I know, I'm just speaking in general terms
 
Aw, thanks.

As a Kuuga fan, it was disappointing for me to find out all of the ugly details about the "Joe Odagiri saga." I've made my dislike of his statements and similar statements well known. I've tracked the ordeal and will present the shebang here, and as objectively as I can. (And I will lazily copy and repaste this whenever the topic comes up.)

It's 1998 and Odagiri is just starting his career. Like many a Japanese actors at the start of their career, his manager looks to tokusatsu as a nice, steady regular gig for a newcomer, and arranges for Odagiri to audition for a Super Sentai. (From Joe's comments referring to the show as being a "year prior to Kuuga," it is presumed that it's GoGoFive he was sent to auditioned for. However, I've wondered if it was really Gingaman, considering Gingaman and Kuuga share the same main producer, Shigenori Takatera, and the story goes that some high up at Toei kept Odagiri in mind for when Kuuga was being cast.)

Odagiri balks at the idea of doing a tokusatsu. He balks hard. "I'm a real actor," he says. "Henshin heroes make me sick," is his reasoning, and one of his oft-quoted lines. When thinking of doing a tokusatsu he wanted to "either die or just give up acting." He's still made to audition and, according to him, he purposely gave a terrible audition in the hopes of never being called back to audition for a tokusatsu series.

It didn't work. Somebody at Toei liked him and made note of him and thought of him when it came time to cast Kuuga. Like Black, Kuuga was a big deal, the popular Rider series' first time on television in quite a while. Pretty much every actor of a particular age in Japan tried out for the lead role. Thinking he was clear of ever having to audition for a tokusatsu, Odagiri's not too happy about his agency arranging for his being seen about Kuuga. But he has to listen to his manager and agency, so he goes...

As we all know, Kuuga was a different approach to tokusatsu, unlike anything tokusatsu had done at that point. That was the goal of Kuuga producer Shigenori Takatera; he wanted to change the face of tokusatsu and he and writer Naruhisa Arakawa wanted it to feel more like an American drama. Odagiri meets with Takatera and finds his pitch fascinating. He doesn't like tokusatsu, but this sounds like something he could see himself doing, something he feels he could sink his teeth into. Takatera's pretty sure he's found his Godai. Odagiri admits that he's never seen a single Kamen Rider series, so Takatera arranges for several episodes of the original series to be sent to Odagiri. Odagiri claims he only watched a little before being completely turned off of the idea again. ("I can't do this kind of stuff!" is his quote) Takatera reassures him and lays out further plans of how his show will be nothing like those old ones. On a leap of faith, Odagiri decides to take the role.

Odagiri has said many, many times that he ended up enjoying the show, he's proud of the success Kuuga had, and that he made friends with a lot of the cast and crew and remains friends with most of them to this day. (IIRC, he even attended the wedding of the actress who played Godai's sister.) Up until that soundbite he gave a TV show (the one that the Tokusatsu Network reported about), he never said anything negative about Kuuga, the show or its quality, itself. His negativity was directed at tokusatsu as a whole, with his own show exempt.

There's been some misunderstanding about his feelings on Kuuga. In some interviews, he's mentioned how difficult and nightmarish it was to make Kuuga, but in a lot of those instances, he was referring to the shooting schedule and the physical demands of the series. Those sentiments, over the years, got entangled with his negativity about the genre as a whole and was warped into a "Odagiri hates Kuuga" thing when that wasn't the issue. Like I said, he had gone on record numerous times saying he liked Kuuga itself. Even with that interview he did that Tokusatsu Network reported about, I've wondered if he was taken out of context slightly or if he was misunderstood. (A lot of what he said was the same thing he always said. "I hated doing it at the time" could easily have been referring to his early feelings.)

If you want to give Odagiri the benefit of doubt, then a majority of his toku-bashing quotes came from that issue of Pict-Up magazine from 2005, just as his popularity was taking off. Could his toku bashing have been bravado, since he's after an indie movie image, an image that doesn't line-up with the star of a hero show? Nobody wants to be typecast, was it his attempt to separate himself from the past and branch out? The general public has their own simplistic idea of what Kamen Rider and tokusatsu is all about, can Joe really be expected to go into all of the minute details about how different Kuuga was each time his being a Rider was brought up?

Still, the idea of him doing one of these Rider movies, right now, is out of the question. Kuuga producer Takatera would definitely need to be involved, and he still has some bad blood over Hibiki. (Which might be letting up, since he recently Tweeted to Toei producers Hideaki Tsukada and Takahito Ohmori the idea of doing an early Heisei VS later Heisei Rider movie.) I think Odagiri will "stoop" and come back to tokusatsu on his own when his mainstream popularity dips and his mainstream roles dry up, or if his kids end up talking him into it. Fans will have to be patient -- Godai won't be returning in a Taisen flick any time soon, but fans could possibly end up seeing a Godai who's nearing 60 in a Rider movie down the road.
_______

(End of objectivity.)

I think there's interesting ways to involve Kuuga or Hibiki characters in these movies, though, but it involves creativity and storytelling capabilities, which Shirakura and Yonemura strongly lack. You could bring back Ichijou and give him G3-Unit armor, keeping that blasted Kuuga and Agito "connection;" you could take the idea from Arakawa's novel of having Mika be a new Kuuga warrior. For Hibiki, you could RIGHT THE SHOW'S WRONGS by bringing back Asumu and having him be the new Hibiki. But these movies just aren't interested in building onto a show or writing a good storyline around old characters and actually USING characters; they just want old faces to slap onto the poster to drum up interest in their 90 minute fighting game masquerading as a movie.

And for the record, I don't like misinformation. I do my best to research and squash that ****.

As a big Kuuga fan, that was great to read (and a little sad). I'd love to see him return one day, it's disappointing we never really got a Kuuga/Agito team up and I'd much prefer these Taisen movies simply focused on the characters they can actually get to return instead of it always being "here's everyone and everything, for about 5 seconds each". I think most people in the thread have said the same thing, but they're banking too heavily on nostalgia that they've already done too many times. The spectacle of it is lost.
 
it's disappointing we never really got a Kuuga/Agito team up

We did though, G3 and Agito.

You might think this sounds condescending but the thing is G3 in terms of narrative and diegetic in-universe function basically is Kuuga (not Godai Yuusuke, just Kuuga the Rider), albeit rendered in a generalized thematic lens (the previous Rider who is firmly allied the police).
And given how, Agito the show doesn't like any form of authority, of course match up isn't to Kuuga's favour.
 
As a big Kuuga fan, that was great to read (and a little sad). I'd love to see him return one day, it's disappointing we never really got a Kuuga/Agito team up and I'd much prefer these Taisen movies simply focused on the characters they can actually get to return instead of it always being "here's everyone and everything, for about 5 seconds each". I think most people in the thread have said the same thing, but they're banking too heavily on nostalgia that they've already done too many times. The spectacle of it is lost.

Yeah i hope so too and speaking of agito at least we hope that the actor who played agito Toshiki Kashu will reprise his role one more in a future superhero taisen film he never said a single no unlike joe who played kuuga and maybe the ones who played G3 and gills Jun Kaname and Yūsuke Tomoi will reprise their roles one more time as well.

And what you said about 'Banking to heavily on nostalgia' you are right that spectacle is lost when they put too much past heroes to come back every year in films i think they should it light it out for a bit and save it for some anniversary seasons or something and not too much

We did though, G3 and Agito.

You might think this sounds condescending but the thing is G3 in terms of narrative and diegetic in-universe function basically is Kuuga (not Godai Yuusuke, just Kuuga the Rider), albeit rendered in a generalized thematic lens (the previous Rider who is firmly allied the police).
And given how, Agito the show doesn't like any form of authority, of course match up isn't to Kuuga's favour.

I guess that shows how agito foreshadows the heisei riders current status and how the secondary rider element is formed .Maybe if joe reprise his role and appear in the same film with Toshiki who will replace as agito maybe the two characters will meet and establish continuity (or not)
 
I think there's interesting ways to involve Kuuga or Hibiki characters in these movies, though, but it involves creativity and storytelling capabilities, which Shirakura and Yonemura strongly lack. You could bring back Ichijou and give him G3-Unit armor, keeping that blasted Kuuga and Agito "connection;" you could take the idea from Arakawa's novel of having Mika be a new Kuuga warrior. For Hibiki, you could RIGHT THE SHOW'S WRONGS by bringing back Asumu and having him be the new Hibiki. But these movies just aren't interested in building onto a show or writing a good storyline around old characters and actually USING characters; they just want old faces to slap onto the poster to drum up interest in their 90 minute fighting game masquerading as a movie.

And for the record, I don't like misinformation. I do my best to research and squash that ****.
To start, the part about Kuuga above this was a great read - Kuuga got me really into this stuff and that whole wall of text was well thought out, and hopefully more on target than some of these rumors.

Now, that aside, I actually think the recent Rider movies do seem interested in some kind of plot.

Remember that weird Faiz retcon in Heisei vs Showa? (And perhaps the general weirdness of that movie in general?) Whether or not it was intentional, they wound up pulling Yuuto back in along with Faiz for the GP, and then in the Rider 4 specials, conclude a surprise story arc with Inui having actually been dead the entire time, and that retcon having been born from Shocker's screwing with history. In essence, they told a story over two movies and some side material, and arguably - for seemingly no reason at all - gave Inui and Kaido final closure.

The execution could have been a lot better, and I hesitate to say this was necessary to do, but I'm definitely impressed given what I've heard of the first two movies.
 

Latest News & Videos

Latest News

Back
Top