The Next Take On Star Trek Will Come From The Guys Behind The D&D Movie

[Peter Paltridge]

Canonical URL

https://popgeeks.com/the-next-take-on-star-trek-will-come-from-the-guys-behind-the-dd-movie/

Star Trek has had its ups and downs, and nowhere is that more evident than in its history with movies. The feature films seemed to ricochet between great and terrible, with a terrible one coming FIRST. A complete reboot was directed by JJ Abrams in 2009 but did not attract a devoted audience and withered away, with its last installment appearing in 2016. Since then Star Trek has been thriving where it started, on television, thanks to Paramount’s need for brand-driven content to attract Paramount+ subscriptions. The idea of a new movie series hasn’t gone away, however. Several notions have been played with, most notably an R-rated ST movie written by Quentin Tarantino (no fooling, it could have happened). Thankfully we’ve been spared that many close-ups of Uhura’s feet. Today Deadline broke the news of another attempt to get Trek trekking back into theaters…and it’s the most promising proposal yet. This movie would come from Jonathan Goldstein and John Francis Daley, the same pair who came up with the amazing Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves in 2023. Seriously, if they can bring to Star Trek the same sense of humor, rich characterization and competent plotting of that movie…we’d have […]
Read original article here:

The Next Take On Star Trek Will Come From The Guys Behind The D&D Movie | PopGeeks.com Forum | Indie Games, Movies, TV, Tabletop & Comics

This Star Trek movie would come from Jonathan Goldstein and John Francis Daley, the same pair who came up with the amazing Dungeons &...

popgeeks.com

 

[KlingonWarrior87]

​

I like the idea of Goldstein and Daley handling a Star Trek film. I enjoyed their Dungeons & Dragons movie because it felt confident and clear. If they apply the same focus to Star Trek, the movie could feel more balanced. I prefer Star Trek stories that do not rely too much on heavy action but still keep the pacing strong. Their writing style might give the characters more defined goals and better emotional scenes. I also think humor, when used with control, can help modern Trek feel less stiff. I do not want nonstop jokes, but natural dialogue would be nice. I only hope the studio does not interfere too much because past Trek films suffered from that. If the directors are given space, the movie could finally step out of the long shadow left by the Abrams era.​

 

[Mestre Yoda]

The Abrams films did not feel like Star Trek to me. Everything moved too fast. Everything relied on spectacle. In contrast, Goldstein and Daley understand character motivations. I think they can build a story where each crew member feels important. Also, their work suggests they know how to handle emotional growth. Star Trek needs that now. It would also be refreshing to see a movie that does not depend on nostalgia. I hope they create a new cast instead of rebooting the same characters again.

 

[Steve Denning]

I honestly do not care which timeline they choose. I only want a clear direction. The franchise feels stuck because every attempt tries to copy something familiar. The D&D filmmakers at least proved they can make a complete narrative without leaning on nostalgia. If they can do the same here, I am fine. The only thing I do not want is another grim tone. Trek works better when it feels hopeful. Even when the story is heavy, the message should still feel constructive.

 

[WickedCharmz]

I am interested in the idea but unsure how it fits the current state of Trek. Television has carried the franchise for years now, and fans are more attached to shows than movies. A new film must feel special. Goldstein and Daley might give it that sense of purpose. Their past work showed confidence with ensemble casts, and Trek always depends on ensemble energy. If they respect the actors and write scenes that allow everyone to contribute, the movie could feel more alive.

 

[Urbanidad]

I do not want too much comedy. I liked the D&D film, but the humor was very noticeable. Star Trek works best when the humor feels natural. If they tone it down, the mixture of drama and science fiction could feel balanced. I am not against their style, but I want it adjusted for Trek. The idea of them writing, directing, and producing gives me hope that they will maintain one consistent tone.