-Batman Returns (1992)
-Batman Forever (1995) (Close enough, different director but it was decent)
-The Dark Knight
-Batman: Mask of the Phantasm
-Batman Beyond: Return of the Joker
I loved them all, but The Dark Knight wins.
**** Frank Miller. **** All*Star Batman and Robin.
Hey, Super Mario Bros was an awesome movie, damn your hides. :/
And... I had to go with Begins. While the first Burton Batman was a very good movie, I never really fully bought Keaton as Batman.
And while Mask of the Phantasm is also incredibly good, it feels out of place on this list. Really, there have been enough animated Batman movies at this point, it could probably have a list of its own.